Superhosts or Plus?

Superhost

Superhosts are Airbnb's top-rated and most experienced hosts. Superhosts have to have an overall rating of at least 4.8/5 based on reviews from at least 50% of their guests within the past year. They also have to have 0 cancellations within the past year. On top of all that, they have to respond to new messages within 24 hours. They take their hosting pretty seriously.
Before I knew about Airbnb, I would always stay in hotels whenever I would go on a trip. I was very picky and skeptical about where I stayed. I would ALWAYS check reviews to make sure I wouldn't be staying in a nasty place.
When I became aware of Airbnb, I immediately searched for the best reviewed places and soon found out about Superhosts. Every time I have used Airbnb, I've always chosen a Superhost. I have NEVER, ever had a bad experience.
The three Superhosts that I've stayed with were all incredibly nice. I have always gone with my boyfriend, and our hosts provided us with welcoming letters, snacks/breakfast treats, coffee/tea, and their own restaurant recommendations. Of course they provided basic amenities, such as towels, pillows, blankets, etc. Some places may offer more or less than others. What they offer will be listed in their home description when booking.
Since I have had amazing experiences with each stay, it's kind of hard to think it's possible to have a bad experience with your Superhost. I'm sure it is possible though. Make sure to do your research. Read reviews, even if it is a Superhost. Of course always be kind and generous to your hosts and the home. Treat it like how you would want your home to be treated. If you ever do have a bad experience, make sure to leave a detailed review to save anyone else in the future.

Airbnb Plus

As for Airbnb Plus homes, they are even better than just choosing to have a Superhost. To be considered an Airbnb Plus home, it has to be visited by an Airbnb worker for an 100+ point quality inspection. These homes are hosted by Superhosts, so you are not only getting the best of the best host, you are also getting the best of the best home. Every Airbnb Plus home is one-of-a-kind and thoughtfully designed. To make sure it's the best of the best, every detail in the home is looked over to make sure there is a maximum level of comfortability. Now, I have never experienced an Airbnb Plus home myself, but they seem pretty darn fabulous. I have looked through Plus homes on the Airbnb website, and the pictures of the homes look absolutely incredible. They are a bit more pricy than just getting a Superhost, but hey if you want 100% satisfaction guaranteed with every aspect of the house, then Airbnb Plus homes will be right up your alley.